When the problem is called cashflow.

Dean Townsend

When the problem is called cashflow.

Why the cash runs short, and how building around what you do best steadies it.

The short answer. Cash flow problems usually start when a business or not-for-profit grows faster than the skills at its centre. The shortage shows up in six common ways, from growth funded out of day-to-day money to funding held back by missing reporting. Managing the cash buys relief. Building the skills and people around what the owner or leader does best is what steadies it.

We have a cashflow problem.

I’ve heard those exact words hundreds of times from owners and leaders.

It’s usually the first thing said on the first call, and there’s a particular kind of pressure behind it. The money is short now, this week, and the worry is real.

Cashflow is the word owners and leaders reach for more than any other, and I’ve worked out why.

The cash is genuinely tight. The stress is genuine too. And the money running short is the one thing you can see, measure and know for certain.

But the cashflow is rarely where the trouble starts.

Across the businesses and not-for-profits I’ve worked with, the shortage is usually the first visible sign that the enterprise has grown faster than the skills at its centre. The challenge has outrun the people carrying it, and the cash is where it shows up first.

That’s why the lasting fix is rarely better cash management.

It’s building the skills and people around what the owner or leader does best, so the enterprise can carry what it has taken on.

I’ve written about that shift in From Stretched To Stoked.

This article is about how it shows up in the cash.

Take the pressure off first.

The immediate pressure has to be dealt with. Wages, the tax office, suppliers. That comes first.

The usual advice is to chase the cashflow itself: tighten it, forecast it, refinance it, manage it. That’s sound, and there are plenty of templates, forecasts and finance options to help.

The relief usually lasts a while. Then the pressure comes back, because what produced the shortage hasn’t changed.

So while the immediate needs are being met, the question to keep asking is what’s producing the shortage. Treating the cash alone is what I call the right answer to the wrong question.

Six ways cash flow problems show up.

Each is a different way the stretch shows up in the cash. They all arrive at the bank account looking the same, but each has a tell that gives it away, and each needs a different first move.

1. When growth is paid for out of working capital.

This one catches good businesses, because it doesn’t look like a problem until the cash runs out.

Something bigger gets taken on: a larger project, a new site, a step up in scale. The growth is funded quietly out of the money needed to run day to day.

Nothing has gone wrong in the accounts. The work is being won. The working capital is simply being spent faster than the work can pay it back.

The tell: the shortage arrives alongside the growth, not against a downturn. Turnover is up, the order book looks healthy, and the cash is tighter than it has ever been.

It shows up in two forms:

The first is the reach that goes wrong. I worked with an engineering business that took on a project larger than anything it had done before, and larger than it could deliver cleanly at that point. The project overran, the overrun became a heavy loss, and the loss consumed the buffer the business had been running on. By the time it reached me, the owner was paying wages hand to mouth and building a debt to the tax office the size of an average mortgage. The immediate work was survival: a refinance and recapitalisation to stop the bleeding. The lasting work was the pivot back to what the business did best. It recovered, and in the years that followed it grew profit year on year.

The second form is quieter and more common, because here the growth is going right. A healthy business wins more work than ever, grows steadily, does nothing wrong, and starves of cash the whole way up. Every new job has to be paid for before it pays out, so the faster it grows, the more of its own money it ties up in front of itself. It’s succeeding its way into a shortage.

Where the stretch sits: in both forms, the challenge jumped ahead of the skills to plan and fund it.

The owner was doing what they do best, winning and delivering the work.

Matching growth to capital needed skills nobody at the centre had the time or training for yet.

The fix is building those skills, or bringing in someone who has them, so the owner can keep doing what grows the business.

2. When the margin has quietly gone.

Sometimes the cash is short for the plainest reason of all.

The work isn’t making enough on each job to fund the next one, and it has been drifting that way long enough to drain the reserves.

Margin rarely collapses in one move. It erodes. Costs lift a little each year and prices don’t. A discount offered to win one client becomes the standard. An input that used to be cheap isn’t anymore.

None of it is dramatic enough on its own to force a response. Then a season comes where the cash doesn’t cover the commitments, and it reads as a cashflow problem when it’s really a pricing and cost problem that has been building for years.

The tell: effort without reward. Everyone is flat out, turnover looks fine, and there’s nothing left at the end of it. When the volume is high and the cash is still short, look at the margin, not the bank balance.

Managing the cash harder won’t fix a job that was underpriced before it started.

Where the stretch sits: pricing and cost reviews are management work, and they’re the first thing squeezed out when the owner is flat out delivering.

The challenge grew, the margin went unwatched, and nobody had the time or the skill to catch it.

The fix is giving that job to someone who’s good at it, or building the skill, so the owner stays on the work they do best.

3. When the business is profitable but there’s no cash.

This one is pure timing, and unlike the growth squeeze, it happens to businesses that aren’t growing at all.

A steady, profitable, well-run business can still be short of cash if the money is trapped between paying for the work and being paid for it. Debtors drift from 30 days to 60 to 90. Stock sits longer than it should. The business ends up funding its customers and its shelves out of its own pocket. The money has been earned. It just hasn’t arrived.

The tell: a profitable set of books sitting next to an empty account. The answer is usually caught in the debtors, the stock or the terms. That’s a different fix from cutting costs or chasing more sales. It’s tightening the timing so the money already earned actually turns up.

Where the stretch sits: chasing debtors and managing stock are systems work, and they slip when everything runs through one stretched person.

The fix is a simple system, or a person who owns collections, so the money comes in without the owner having to chase it.

4. When the borrowing doesn’t match what it bought.

Debt causes a cash shortage less often through its size than through its shape.

A loan over too short a term, or repayments that don’t line up with what the money funded, will squeeze the cash even when the business underneath is sound.

There’s a version of this worth naming, because the instinct behind it feels so responsible. Debt feels like a weight, so owners try to clear it fast. They throw extra money at the loan and trim whatever looks discretionary to find it. I tell the full story of a hospitality business that paid its debt down faster by starving the marketing and training that drove its revenue. It lost far more than the interest it saved.

The tell: the business is sound, but the repayments don’t fit.

The fix is the structure of the borrowing, not another round of belt-tightening.

Where the stretch sits: structuring finance is a specialist skill most owners only need every few years.

When the skill isn’t there, instinct fills the gap, and the responsible-feeling instinct is often the wrong one.

The fix is borrowing the skill rather than learning it: good advice on the structure, while the owner stays clear on what the borrowing is for.

5. When a decision is being paid for by not making it.

This is the quietest cause, and it hides best, because there’s nothing in the accounts to point at. A decision that needs making isn’t being made, and the cost of leaving it open is paid, week after week, in cash.

It might be a client who is no longer worth serving.

A role that should have changed a year ago.

A part of the business that has stopped earning its keep.

A hard conversation between partners that keeps getting put off.

None of it shows up as a line item.

It shows up as a slow leak that no amount of cash management seems to seal.

The tell: a shortage nobody can quite account for, sitting next to a decision everyone has been avoiding. If the books can’t explain the leak, the cause may not be in the books at all.

Where the stretch sits: the decisions that stay open are usually the ones furthest from what the owner or leader does best.

A hard conversation, letting a client go, changing a role.

When a challenge sits outside your skills it feels heavy, and heavy decisions wait.

The fix is building the skill to make that call, or having someone alongside to help make it.

6. When the money exists but the reporting doesn’t.

A charity doing genuinely good work came under acute cash pressure when its funding was withheld.

On the surface it was the plainest cashflow crisis there is.

The money that kept the doors open had stopped arriving.

The money hadn’t gone anywhere. It was being held back because acquittals had been missed and the reporting lacked the detail the funder needed.

The frontline volunteers who cared deeply about the people they served, didn’t have the skills or the knowledge of what the funder required.

Above them, the chief executive was spread far too thin, with no accountability framework to lean on.

The immediate work was the acquittal itself: an interim plan in front of the funding body to clear the block.

But the fix that held was built around the people rather than against them. We tightened the reporting by sharing the wins.

Each month the volunteers’ work was gathered up and told as a story of what they’d done and who they’d helped, in an internal newsletter that celebrated them by name. The volunteers loved it. And in the telling, the very data the acquittals needed was being collected as a matter of course. The chief executive stopped chasing the frontline for information they found tedious, and the job narrowed to making sure the information flowed.

The funder renewed the funding with tighter reporting attached.

From that footing the organisation secured further funding and expanded.

Over three years, the number of people it helped grew from around 300 a year to more than 1,000.

The tell: the money exists but something is blocking it.

For not-for-profits, that’s often reporting, acquittals or compliance. The cash crisis was never about cash. It was about the capability to report the outcomes that released it.

Where the stretch sits: the volunteers were great at the frontline work, not at reporting, and the chief executive was carrying too much.

The fix that held was built around what the volunteers did best, telling the story of who they’d helped, and the reporting came with it.

Building around what you do best.

Look back across the six and the same pattern shows through.

In almost every case, the business or organisation grew, and the challenge of running it grew faster than the skills at the centre.

Each of the six is the same imbalance showing up in a different place.

When challenge and skill are out of balance, stress follows.

The cash shortage is often where that stress shows up first.

When they’re back in balance, people perform better, decisions get made, and the cash tends to follow.

That’s why the lasting fixes across all six are built around the people.

Build the skills that are missing, or bring in people to cover them, so the owner or leader can spend more of their time on what they do best.

I’ve written more about that shift in the article From Stretched to Stoked.

The cash is the signal.

A cash shortage is information.

It’s telling you something upstream is out of balance, and it’s worth reading rather than just managing.

Growth funded from working capital, a margin that has quietly gone, profit stuck in the timing, borrowing that doesn’t fit, a decision left open and funding held back by reporting are six different problems. They all arrive at the bank account looking identical.

Manage the cash and the relief is temporary.

Take the pressure off, then build the skills and people around what you do best, and the cash tends to look after itself. So does the worry that came with it.

Questions owners and leaders ask.

Why do cash flow problems keep coming back?

Because managing the cash treats the symptom. Forecasting, refinancing and tightening give relief, but the shortage returns if the enterprise has grown faster than the skills at its centre. Building the skills and people around what the owner or leader does best is what holds.

Why is my business profitable but has no cash?

Usually timing. Profit is earned when the work is done, but cash arrives when the customer pays. If debtors stretch from 30 to 90 days, stock sits too long, or growth ties money up in new work, a profitable business can run short. Check debtors, stock and terms first.

Can a growing business have cash flow problems?

Yes, and it’s one of the most common causes. Every new job has to be paid for before it pays out, so faster growth ties up more of the business’s own money. Turnover rises while the bank balance falls. The fix is matching growth to the capital and capability to carry it.

Do not-for-profits have cash flow problems too?

Yes, and the cause is often reporting rather than money. Funding can be held back when acquittals are missed or outcome reporting lacks detail. The fix is building that reporting into the frontline work, so the data is collected as a matter of course.

If the cash is tight and you can’t see why.

Start with a conversation.

In 45 minutes we’ll work through what’s pressing, what’s behind it, and how the load is sitting with you.

You’ll leave with a fresh perspective and an experienced view on what to do next.

Book a conversation with Dean.

No cost. No obligation. Virtual meeting or call.

 

, , , , ,

Dean Townsend

Dean Townsend is a Strategic Advisor and Founder of Stoked Strategic Solutions, with 35+ years’ experience working with owners and leaders. He’s led finance for a multinational and worked alongside owners, boards and leadership teams through challenges, change and uncertainty. He’s helped hundreds of businesses and not-for-profits steady their cashflow and grow, by building around what their owners and leaders do best.